Village of Pittsford
PLANNING and ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
April 22, 2002 - Regular Meeting held on Monday at 7:30 P.M.
| PRESENT: |
| |
Chairperson: |
Remegia Mitchell |
| |
Members: |
Linda Lanphear
Harold Danko
Sally Chamberlin
Ted Weniger |
| |
Attorney: |
John C. Osborn |
| |
Building Inspector: |
Skip Bailey |
| |
Recording Secretary: |
Mary Marowski |
| |
|
|
Chairperson Mitchell called the meeting to order
at 7:30 PM.
PLANNING BOARD
1. Pittsford Little League - Bob Ford Field
- Site Plan Approval
Present: Steve Bailey, Representative for the lessee (Pittsford
Little League)
Proposed: To obtain site plan approval for the construction
of a new equipment shed and bathrooms.
The secretary read the legal notice that was
published in the Brighton Pittsford Post on April 10, 2002:
"Please take notice that a Public Hearing will be held before
the Village of Pittsford Planning Board at the Village Hall, 21
North Main Street, Pittsford, New York, on Monday, April 22, 2002
at 7:30 P.M. to consider an application made by the New York State
Canal Corporation (owner) and Pittsford Little League (lessee),"
for a site plan approval to include the construction of a new equipment
shed and restrooms on property known as Bob Ford Field, located
on South Street in the Village of Pittsford, NY pursuant to Article
XVII, Chapter 210-83, Site Plan Approval, of the Code of the Village
of Pittsford."
SEQR: Chairperson Mitchell stated this
is a Type II Action under SEQR 617.5, #2 and #7. No further review
is necessary.
Discussion: Mr. Steve Bailey stated the
use of Bob Ford Field is seasonal with the season ending in September.
The work on the facility will begin as soon as all approvals are
received with an expected completion by the end of May. The proposal
is for the removal of the existing equipment shed and the replacement
of a new larger permanent facility. This facility will house the
storage of all equipment as well as have bathroom accommodations
for 2 men and 2 women. This will eliminate the need for port-a-potties
and the existing storage cubes. The snack bar building will also
be upgraded with a new roof and siding. One or two small trees located
on the perimeter may need to be taken down but no other landscaping
changes are planned. A self-contained, no vent pipe, threshold monitor
alarm, septic system, holding 1800 gallons, will be maintained by
McKenna Plumbing (contract). This septic system will be located
underground next to the building. The unit will have a manhole cover.
For safety concerns, locking the manhole cover was discussed.
Russ Smith - 22 South Street - stated that it
is a common practice at all Monroe County parks to have holding
tanks.
Public Hearing opened: Chairperson Mitchell
opened the public hearing.
Building Inspector Skip Bailey suggested that
site plan approval be conditional for the removal of all trailers
and port-a-potties upon completion of the structure.
The Board raised some concerns regarding the type
of materials to be used regarding the construction of the facility.
The cinder block portion of the concession building will remain
and possibly standard wood siding will be used for the remainder.
The application needs to be reviewed by the Architectural Preservation
and Review Board. There were also concerns raised regarding a 'safe
walk zone' near the concession stand on the side of the driveway.
No other comments were submitted regarding this
application.
Public Hearing closed: There being no further
comments, Chairperson Mitchell closed the Public Hearing.
Motion: Chairperson Mitchell made a motion,
seconded by Member Danko, to accept the site plan proposed with
the following conditions: 1. Width of the 'safe zone walkway' should
be a minimum of 3' and protected by bollards on the side of the
driveway. 2. Trailer, temporary storage units, and port-a-potties
be removed after the completion. 3. Manhole cover to the holding
tank is to be secured. 4. Board approval will be needed if additional
lighting is needed. 5. APRB approval needed.
Vote: Weniger - yes, Chamberlin - yes,
Mitchell - yes, Lanphear - yes, Danko - yes. Motion carried.
The decision was filed in the Office of the Village Clerk on 4/22/02.
2. Keith Miller - 27 North Main Street - Site
Plan Approval
Present: Keith Miller, owner
Proposed: To obtain site plan approval for the construction
of a parking area for a bed and breakfast home and installation
of a free standing sign.
The secretary read the legal notice that was
published in the Brighton Pittsford Post on April 10, 2002:
"Please take notice that a Public Hearing will be held before
the Village of Pittsford Planning Board at the Village Hall, 21
North Main Street, Pittsford, New York on Monday, April 22, 2002
at 7:30 P. M. to consider an application made by Keith Miller, owner,
for site plan approval to include a free-standing sign and the construction
of a parking area for a Bed and Breakfast establishment to be located
at 27 North Main Street, Pittsford, NY pursuant to Article XVII,
Chapter 210-83, Site Plan Approval, of the Code of the Village of
Pittsford."
SEQR: The applicant has requested a Special
Use Permit from the Board of Trustees. A SEQR application was filed
as a result of the April 9th Trustee meeting. The Planning Board
has been asked to review this application for SEQR issues and for
a lead agency declaration.
Discussion: Mr. Miller had applied to the
Board of Trustees for a Special Use Permit in April for the operation
of a Bed and Breakfast at 27 North Main Street (former Zornow estate).
He is appearing before the Planning Board conditionally to obtain
site plan approval for a parking area in the location of the existing
concrete based garage. The owner's intent is to demolish the garage
and utilize the location for the availability of five parking places
(one for each of the guestrooms and one for himself). There may
be a need to remove one pine tree that is behind the existing garage
to make room for the parking area. Mr. Miller is also proposing
an illuminated (incandescent) sign to read "Canal Lamp Inn"
to be placed between the walkway and the driveway. There will also
be four Mohawk lanterns (kerosene lamps converted to electric) hanging
from metal poles along the walkway. The visibility from the canal
is limited because the canal perimeter of the property is wooded.
Public Hearing opened: Chairperson Mitchell
opened the public hearing.
It was stated that a decision can not be made
at this time because the application is considered incomplete due
to the following: 1. No Special Use Permit has been issued; 2. SEQR
review needs to be completed before Planning Board will grant site
plan approval; 3. The site plan for parking is dependent upon the
APRB approval for the demolition of the garage.
Chairperson Mitchell stated there is no SEQR concern
sited by the Planning Board. She further stated to request the Board
of Trustees be the 'lead agency' regarding this application. A letter
will be sent to the Board of Trustees for their May 14th meeting
given this decision.
Member Weniger sited there are other concerns
the Planning Board has regarding the issuance of a Special Use Permit
for the Bed and Breakfast: 1. Owner residency/occupancy; 2. Future
plans for the back property (currently used as a rental property
for the owner's sister-in-law) and how those plans will impact the
neighbors (Bolger's and Hayden's) properties. 3. The Special Use
Permit be limited to the front portion of the property only with
limitations placed upon the applicant. Member Weniger will draft
a letter on behalf of the Planning Board to the Board of Trustees
for their May 14th meeting siting these concerns.
No other comments were submitted regarding this
application.
Public Hearing is left open pending
the decisions of the Board of Trustees and the Architectural Preservation
and Review Board.
Motion: Chairperson Mitchell made a motion,
seconded by Member Danko, to draft a letter to the Board of Trustees
declaring them as lead agency in the SEQR review of the Bed and
Breakfast located at 27 North Main Street. She further stated another
letter will be drafted regarding the Board's concerns regarding
the issuance of a Special Use Permit.
Vote: Weniger - yes, Chamberlin - yes,
Mitchell - yes, Lanphear - yes, Danko - yes. Motion carried.
The decision was filed in the Office of the Village Clerk on 4/22/02.
ZONING BOARD
1. Minds Eye Communication - 34 State Street
- Renewal of 6-Month Temporary Zoning Permit
Present: Eric Smith, Tenant
Proposed: To obtain a renewal of the Temporary Use Permit.
The secretary read the legal notice that was
published in the Brighton Pittsford Post on March 13, 2002: "Please
take notice that a public hearing will be held before the Village
of Pittsford Zoning Board of Appeals at the Village Hall, 21 North
Main Street, Pittsford, New York, on Monday, April 22, 2002 at 7:30
P. M. to consider an application made by Robert Michaels, assignee
landlord for Messala Associates, for the renewal of a temproary
six-month zoning permit to allow the use and occupation of an advertising
agency, a use not permitted in this B1 Retail Business District,
at 34 State Street pursuant to Chapter 210-109, Temporary permits,
of the Code of the Village of Pittsford."
SEQR: Chairperson Mitchell stated this
is a Type II Action under SEQR, 617.5C, #15.
Attorney Osborn stated Robert Michaels is a client
of his law firm, however, in this respect to this application, he
sees no conflict of interest.
Public Hearing opened: Chairperson Mitchell
opened the public hearing.
Discussion: This is a re-application for
a second six-month temporary permit (18 month maximum) for Minds
Eye Communication. This property, zoned B1 Retail Business District,
is being occupied as office space for an advertising agency. This
building is not located on or visible from a main street. The property
is well maintained. The tenant stated it is his intent to stay in
the Village in a suitable location.
No other comments were submitted regarding this
application.
Public Hearing closed: There being no further
comments, Chairperson Mitchell closed the Public Hearing.
Motion: Chairperson Mitchell made a motion,
seconded by Member Lanphear, to approve the extension for a temporary
six-month zoning permit with the following conditions: 1. The applicant
must re-apply at the end of six months (October 2002). 2. Sign must
stay as allowed per Village Code. 3. Temporary permit is limited
to the sub-lessee, Minds Eye Communication, only.
Vote: Weniger - yes, Chamberlin - yes,
Mitchell - yes, Lanphear - yes, Danko - yes. Motion carried.
The decision was filed in the Office of the Village Clerk on 4/22/02.
Building Inspector's Report
Mr. Bailey reported the following:
- Jaya Juicery & Natural Foods is seeking
a Special Permit from the Board of Trustees. They are considering
to occupy a space in the Hunter's Building next to Ensenat's Deli.
A parking variance may be required.
- A second juice bar/Yoga studio applicant is
considering to occupy the former Shoe Concepts/Mole Hole location.
- A complaint was received regarding the garbage
dumpster located behind the Recovery Caboose which is used by
Rick's Prime Rib House.
- The litigation issue regarding the Subtelney
property on South Main Street has been settled. Window replacement
will take place over a three year period.
Member Items
- A concern was raised regarding the property
that is now for sale on Boughton Ave with respect to it being
a single/double resident home.
- A concern was raised regarding the use of
the home formerly owned by Mr. Rogers.
- Avante Garbe: plastic flowers are no longer
on the sidewalk.
Minutes April 8, 2002
Motion: Chairperson Mitchell made a motion, seconded by Member
Chamberlin, to approve the minutes as presented.
Vote: Weniger - yes, Chamberlin - yes, Mitchell - yes, Lanphear
- abstain, Danko - yes. Motion carried. The decision was filed
in the Office of the Village Clerk on 4/22/02.
Adjournment
There being no further business, Chairperson Mitchell adjourned
the meeting at 9:30 PM.
Mary A. Marowski, Recording Secretary
|